Jorge Luis Borges: His background and the influence of foreign
philosophers and writers
Jorge Luis Borges was born in Buenos Aires. His family included
British ancestry and he learned English before Spanish. Jorge Guillermo
Borges, (his father), was a lawyer and a psychology teacher, who
demonstrated the paradoxes of Zeno on a chessboard for his son. In the
large house was also a library and garden which enchanted Borges's
imagination. Borges's mother, Leonor Acevedo Haedo was a translator. In
1914 the family moved to Geneva, where Borges learned French and German
and received his BA from the College of Geneva. According to a story,
Borges's father, worried about his son's sexual initation, sent him to a
prostitute in the red-light district area, the Place Dubourg de Four.
There Borges started to think that his father was her "client". Borges's
visit failed miserably and perhaps contributed to his lifelong
difficulties with women, although he did marry twice.
 |
Schopenhauer |
 |
George Berkeley |
 |
Shakespeare |
Influenced by the English philosopher George Berkeley, (18th century
Irish philosopher (1685-1753), Borges played with the idea that concrete
reality may consist only of mental perceptions. The philosophy, is known
as 'Subjective idealism' - a theory of perception. The theory describes
a relationship between human experience of the external world and that
world itself, in which objects are nothing more than collections (or
bundles) of sense data to those who perceive them. The "real world" is
only one possible in the infinite series of realities. These themes were
examined among others in the classical short stories 'The Garden of
Forking Paths' and 'Death and the Compass', in which Borges showed his
fondness of detective formula. In the story the calm, rational detective
and adventurer Erik Lönnrot, finds himself trapped in cryptographic
labyrinths in a fantastical city, while attempting to solve a series of
crimes. The detective stories bring order to chaos. "In this chaotic era
of ours," said Borges, "one thing is has humbly maintained the classic
virtues - the detective story. A detective story cannot be understood
without a beginning, middle, and end... I would say in defense of the
detective novel that it needs no defense, though now read with a certain
disdain, it is safeguarding order in an era of disorder".
As a writer Borges drew on his European education and brought
attention to ancient philosophers and mystics, Jewish Cabbalists and
Gnostics, French poets, Cervantes, Dante and Schopenhauer. Above all
English writers as Shakespeare, John Milton, Samuel Taylor Coleridge,
Thomas De Quincey, H.G. Wells, and G.K. Chesterton. When many Latin
American writers dealt with political or social subjects, Borges focused
on eternal questions and the literary heritage of the world. However,
Borges criticized his friend Pablo Neruda, a politically highly visible
author, for denouncing all the South American dictators except Juan
Perón, Borges's own arch-enemy. "Perón was then in power. It seems that
Neruda had a lawsuit pending with his publisher in Buenos Aires. That
publisher, as you probably know, has always been his principal source of
income."
Borges was also drawn to Arab literature, including the imaginary
Arabic of Edward Fitzgerald's Rubáiyát and the tales of the One Thousand
and One Nights and to mystical traditions, from Sufism to the Kabbalah.
Though these works arrived via Spanish culture, he was also shaped by
local influences. At least since the duel between Domingo Sarmiento's
anti-caudillo and anti-gaucho tract of 1845, Facundo 'Civilization and
Barbarism', and José Hernández's 1872 dialect masterpiece, 'The Gaucho
Martín Fierro', Argentine writing has been tangled in political
struggles between the city and the provinces, between liberal reform and
caudillo independence, between the criollismo emphasis on Spanish
ancestry and the cosmopolitan fact of the country's immigrant history.
Borges also knew Leopoldo Lugones, the poet who in 1913 delivered a
series of anti-Sarmiento lectures at the Teatro Odeón in Buenos Aires.
He argued that the wealthy criollos of Argentina should model their
national identity on gaucho culture-a bizarre suggestion, since the rich
estancia holders had thrown the native peoples and gauchos celebrated in
Hernández's epic off their land. At odds with Lugones for much of his
life, Borges eventually grew to admire him deeply. Even as the older
poet's nationalism developed over time into outright fascism, Borges
dedicated his book of poems El Hacedor (The Maker), from 1960, to him.
Another important early influence was his father's friend Evaristo
Carriego, who died from tuberculosis at 29 and was a bitter enemy of
Lugones throughout his short life. In 1930 Borges would write a set of
biographical essays celebrating Carriego and his musical poetry drawn
from the barrios of Buenos Aires. The varied 'Poems of the night'
continually evoke not only Borges's blindness and reflections on death
but also the lively world of Carriego. 'Street With a Pink Corner
Store,' 'St. John's Eve,' 'Almost a Last Judgment' and other poems
reveal the insomniac Borges walking the shadowy streets of Buenos Aires
all night, bringing news of the dusk to the dawn.
A lifelong admirer of the philosophy of Berkeley and Schopenhauer,
Borges had little time for either empiricism or the conventions of
realism. As he continually drew on legends and referred to realities
that may or may not be true, he also turned to dreams. They brought him
the paradoxical certainty that they weren't true (except when they came
true, as he so believed they so often did). He therefore particularly
loved legends of dreaming, such as the story of the Chinese philosopher
Zhuangzi, who dreams he is a butterfly and awakens to find he is
himself, and then wonders if in truth he is Zhuangzi who dreamed he was
a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming he is Zhuangzi. And he liked to cite
the long poem 'The Conference of the Birds,' by the Persian mystic Farid
ud-Din Attar. A group of birds traverse seven valleys in pursuit of the
Simurgh, king of all birds. They gradually discover 'they are the
Simurgh and that the Simurgh is each one and all of them.' Themes of the
inter-relatedness of all beings and all destinies, of the other becoming
the self, seemed to both frighten and console Borges throughout his
life.
Borges's fictional universe was born of his vast and esoteric
readings of literature, philosophy, and theology. He saw man's search
for meaning in an infinite universe as a fruitless effort. Borges
considered the central riddle as time rather than space. He believed in
an infinite series of times, in a growing net of divergent, convergent
and parallel times. This network of times approached one another, then
forked, broke off, were unaware of one another for centuries, yet
embraced all possibilities that we can conceive of. The theological
speculations of Gnosticism and the Cabala gave Borges the idea for many
of his plots. In an interview he said that when he was a boy, he found
an engraving of the seven wonders of the world, (one of which portrayed
a circular labyrinth). It frightened him and the maze became one of his
recurrent nightmares. "Almost instantly, I understood: 'The garden of
forking paths' was the chaotic novel; the phrase 'the various futures
(not to all)' suggested to me the forking in time, not in space. A broad
rereading of the work confirms the theory. In all fictional works, each
time a man is confronted with several alternatives, he chooses one and
eliminates the others; in the fiction of Ts'ui Pęn, he chooses
(simultaneously), all of them. He creates, in this way, diverse futures,
diverse time which themselves also proliferate and fork."
Another recurrent image is the mirror, which reflects different
identities. The idea for the short story 'Borges y yo' was came from the
double, who was looking at him - the alter ego, the other I. There is a
well-known man, who writes his stories, a name in some biographical
dictionary, and the real person. "So my life is a point-counterpoint, a
kind of fugue and a falling away. Everything winds up being lost to me
and everything falls into oblivion, or into the hands of the other man."
It is undoubtedly this philosophical thinking which makes Borges' work
so fascinating and pleasurable to read.
|