Wines of The Times:
Looking for love at bargain prices
A complex wine is a good thing. A complex wine label is death to
sales - at least, some of the time. Take German wines, for example. Too
often, consumers are confronted with the choking union of German words
and Gothic script. Add to that arcane wine rules that offer too much
information on a label but convey little of what's in a bottle, and the
net effect is to deaden demand for some of the world's greatest wines.
But the Burgundy label? Now, that's a thing of intricate beauty. With
a profusion of details concerning producers, geography, vineyard and
vineyard rating, the Burgundy label, too, can appear complicated and
intimidating. Unlike the German label, though, the Burgundy label
conveys precise information and is well worth the effort to understand.
Burgundy lovers can only wish that the label would have the same
dampening effect on sales as the German one. Alas, good Burgundy is
always in demand. There's never enough to go around.
The issue with a bottle of Burgundy is generally not what style of
wine it will be. You know it will be a dry red wine. You just don't know
how good it will be. While the overall level of quality in Burgundy has
improved significantly in the last 25 years, it is still hard to know
where you will end up on the spectrum, from something thin, sharp and
mean to a wine that comes as close to heaven as is possible for a mere
liquid.
Conceptually, the Burgundy label represents the definition of terror.
At the low end are the most general geographical definitions: Bourgogne,
for example, for the Burgundy region as a whole. That means the grapes
can come from anywhere in Burgundy, most likely from several different
areas of lower status. At the high end are labels with maximum
specificity, indicating that all the grapes in a wine come from a single
vineyard, La TŸche, for example, or Chambertin.
Here's where things get tricky. Vineyards can be good and they can be
bad, so all the talk of terror won't help the wine at all if the
vineyard is no good. In an effort to sort things out, Burgundy
classifies its better vineyards as premier cru, and the best as grand
cru. You can imagine, given the already high demand for Burgundy, that
such designations are tantamount to saying, "Charge a fortune for this
bottle.''
Usually, though not always, they are less expensive than premier and
grand cru wines. The exception is when you find a wine from a simple
appellation made by a top producer or n,gociant, like Maison Leroy.
For the tasting, Florence Fabricant and I were joined by Beth von
Benz, a wine consultant, and Scott Mayger, general manager at Telepan, a
restaurant on the Upper West Side. We decided to stick with the
C"te d'Or because we were curious about how good, or bad, these
village wines would be. Good deals for pleasing wines can often be found
in the C"te Chalonnaise to the south, from villages like Givry, Rully
and Mercurey. Conversely, famous C"te d'Or villages like
Gevrey-Chambertin and Pommard have long had the reputation as
underachievers, getting by on their venerated names rather than the
quality of the wines.
Meanwhile, consumers can easily fall prey to romance. Whose tastebuds
would not be aroused by the prospects of a Vosne-Roman,e, the site of
some of the most heralded vineyards in the world, like Roman,e-Conti and
La TŸche? A village Vosnes-Roman,e, of course, benefits greatly by
association.
Nonetheless the 25 wines we tasted offered a clear idea of why
Burgundy is so beloved. The best of these wines were harmonious and deep
with pure, elegant flavors. "How quiet Burgundy is,'' Mr. Mayger noted.
"The wines don't assault you.''
(NEWYORK TIMES)
|