LA Times editor is forced out

Dean Baquet, the editor of The Los Angeles Times who defied orders from his corporate bosses to cut jobs, was forced out of his own job today, shocking his newsroom just as it was gearing up to cover election returns.

He is to leave his post on Friday and be replaced by James O'Shea, the managing editor of The Chicago Tribune, who will start Monday.

Mr. Baquet's departure follows that of the paper's publisher, Jeffrey M. Johnson, who with Mr. Baquet in September had openly objected to cuts ordered by Tribune Company and was fired last month.

David Hiller, who replaced Mr. Johnson as publisher, said in a statement that he had been having discussions with Mr. Baquet about staffing levels and that the company maintained its position that further cuts might be necessary. But Mr. Baquet still considered them excessive.

"After considerable discussion during the past several weeks, Dean and I concluded that we have significant differences on the future direction of The Times," Mr. Hiller said.

Colleagues of Mr. Baquet's said the firing had less to do with a dispute over job cuts than his vocal resistance to them, made plain in a speech last month in New Orleans in which he encouraged editors at other newspapers to "push back" against owners who wanted to cut newsroom staffs.

In fact, when Mr. Hiller addressed the newsroom, he said he expected no job cuts at least for the rest of this year, and he told editors that it was still possible that any further cuts could be reached through attrition, according to people at the paper.

Mr. Hiller said in an interview later that public debate was not a "fatal problem." But he added, of Mr. Baquet's speech in New Orleans: "I did not think it was helpful to Dean and me in working through things. My issue was what it said about whether we saw eye to eye on how we lead this great newspaper forward."

Colleagues said Mr. Baquet was considering having lunch next week with David Geffen, one of three local billionaires who have expressed interest in acquiring The Los Angeles Times. The Tribune Company, under pressure from investors, is considering selling some or all of its assets, which also include 10 other papers and two dozen television stations.

The hope of some in the newsroom is that Mr. Geffen, or someone, buys the paper and rehires Mr. Baquet as editor.The Los Angeles Times has steadily lost circulation over the years, falling to 776,000 daily as of Sept. 30 from a peak of 1.2 million in 1990.

The two-month showdown in Los Angeles has been a dramatic example of the conflict between many newsrooms and boardrooms across the country as newspapers face an economic slump and continued demands by Wall Street for improved financial results.

The stock prices of most public newspaper companies have fallen over the last two years, yet many of their publications remain profitable. The Los Angeles Times reported that its operating profit margin was 20 percent, higher than that of the average Fortune 500 company.

Mr. Hiller said in his statement that changes were "threatening the financial position of the whole industry," and that the cuts were not about maintaining high profit margins. "Look no further than recent reports on other large metro papers in Boston, Philadelphia, Dallas and San Francisco," he said.

Many colleagues of Mr. Baquet said they have considered his departure a matter of time. The news was supposed to be announced on Thursday, but word began leaking today and by mid-afternoon Mr. Baquet had confirmed it to his staff. "Believe me, I didn't want it to come out this way," he wrote in a memo. He could not be reached for comment.

Many on the staff of The Los Angeles Times said the news caught them off guard and threw the paper into turmoil, coming on election night, one of the busiest and most complicated for news organizations. Mr. Baquet's departure, on top of the potential sale of the paper, creates even further uncertainty on the staff.

Mr. O'Shea, the new editor of The Los Angeles Times, was named managing editor at The Chicago Tribune in 2001. Before then, he was deputy managing editor for news and worked at the paper in a variety of assignments, having joined the paper in 1979 after working as a reporter, editor and Washington correspondent for The Des Moines Register.

Mr. Baquet's staff gave him a sustained ovation as he stood on a desk in the newsroom to announce that he was leaving. He said he did not want them to dwell on the last month but to remember the last six years, during which the paper broke news, forced laws to be changed and won Pulitzer Prizes. His management team stood behind him.

Mr. Hiller climbed on the desk afterward. He said he had hoped this day would never come. He also said that there would be no reductions at least for the rest of the year, but that The Los Angeles Times could not escape the changes that are sweeping the industry.

www.nytimes.com